We are independent & ad-supported. We may earn a commission for purchases made through our links.
Advertiser Disclosure
Our website is an independent, advertising-supported platform. We provide our content free of charge to our readers, and to keep it that way, we rely on revenue generated through advertisements and affiliate partnerships. This means that when you click on certain links on our site and make a purchase, we may earn a commission. Learn more.
How We Make Money
We sustain our operations through affiliate commissions and advertising. If you click on an affiliate link and make a purchase, we may receive a commission from the merchant at no additional cost to you. We also display advertisements on our website, which help generate revenue to support our work and keep our content free for readers. Our editorial team operates independently of our advertising and affiliate partnerships to ensure that our content remains unbiased and focused on providing you with the best information and recommendations based on thorough research and honest evaluations. To remain transparent, we’ve provided a list of our current affiliate partners here.
Politics

Our Promise to you

Founded in 2002, our company has been a trusted resource for readers seeking informative and engaging content. Our dedication to quality remains unwavering—and will never change. We follow a strict editorial policy, ensuring that our content is authored by highly qualified professionals and edited by subject matter experts. This guarantees that everything we publish is objective, accurate, and trustworthy.

Over the years, we've refined our approach to cover a wide range of topics, providing readers with reliable and practical advice to enhance their knowledge and skills. That's why millions of readers turn to us each year. Join us in celebrating the joy of learning, guided by standards you can trust.

What is a Citizen's Arrest?

Michael Pollick
By
Updated: May 23, 2024
Views: 56,172
Share

Despite what many people think, the concept of citizen's arrest is not to circumvent legitimate law enforcement or arbitrarily detain people without proof of a crime. Today, it exists as more of an emergency or stop-gap power granted to ordinary citizens at the behest of law enforcement officers.

Citizen's arrest means that a private citizen has the right to detain suspected criminals until proper law enforcement personnel can assume custody. The practice can be traced back to English common law during the Middle Ages, although each country or state can modify the rules of engagement. During the earliest days of modern justice systems, performing a citizen's arrest was a much more common practice. Merchants would routinely detain shoplifters and thieves caught in the act, often bringing them directly to a local constable's office for trial. As criminals became better armed and law enforcement became more readily available, the popularity of this type o arrest seemed to wane.

Modern law enforcement officers strongly discourage untrained civilians from making a citizen's arrest. The risk of bodily injury or death is much too high, and the average response time of trained police officers is significantly faster. But under certain circumstances, such an arrest can provide enough time for the proper authorities to arrive. One of the main problems with a citizen's arrest, however, is the possibility of making a mistake. Unlike a failed attempt to resuscitate a victim through CPR, there is very little if any 'Good Samaritan' protection for private citizens who detain an innocent suspect.

One criteria for a legal citizen's arrest is the immediacy of the crime. The ideal circumstance is to catch the suspected criminal in the very act of committing a crime. A person witnessing a mugging can seize the mugger and hold him until a police officer arrives, for example.

Another scenario for a proper citizen's arrest would be a serious potential for a crime to be committed soon. If a person saw a masked man with a crowbar walking towards a vehicle, it can be reasonably assumed that a crime is about to take place. The witness can detain the masked man. This would still be true even if the 'crime' turned out to be a misunderstanding. If someone sees a man climbing through a broken window, he cannot be held responsible for false arrest if the man turns out to be the owner of the building who lost his keys.

Because the act of detaining an armed or physically powerful suspect can be extremely dangerous, police officers often suggest that citizens spend their time observing the suspect and the crime scene instead. If the witness can provide a physical description of the suspect or a license plate number, the police may be able to find the suspect themselves. The safer equivalent is a signed statement, with the intention of pressing criminal charges later. Sometimes, a police officer will ask a witness or victim to tell the suspect that he or she has been placed under citizen's arrest. This gives the police more legal authority to detain the suspect until he or she can be properly processed into the legal system.

Share
Historical Index is dedicated to providing accurate and trustworthy information. We carefully select reputable sources and employ a rigorous fact-checking process to maintain the highest standards. To learn more about our commitment to accuracy, read our editorial process.
Michael Pollick
By Michael Pollick
As a frequent contributor to Historical Index, Michael Pollick uses his passion for research and writing to cover a wide range of topics. His curiosity drives him to study subjects in-depth, resulting in informative and engaging articles. Prior to becoming a professional writer, Michael honed his skills as an English tutor, poet, voice-over artist, and DJ.
Discussion Comments
By MrTideman — On Sep 05, 2012

Thanks for writing that: "Citizen's arrest means that a private citizen has the right to *detain* suspected criminals until proper law enforcement personnel can assume *custody...*" as in, to give a verbal instruction to the criminal to halt until the police arrive to either, as written here of: a signed statement, or that after the halt of the act, then for the police officer, being a "peace officer" to serve or "issue" an RSA Chapter 594:14 Summons to the criminal to appear in court on a certain day and time to have to answer to the criminal charge. --JSH

By anon228820 — On Nov 10, 2011

I'd say that you can convince several people not to leave the premises if you hold a gun on them, but the arriving officer may not see your actions the same way you do. I personally wouldn't hold a suspect under citizen's arrest with a gun unless I knew the police were aware of the true situation. Many officers are trained to draw their own weapons at the mere sight of a gun, so I'd say it may not be strictly illegal, but pretty inadvisable.

There's also the chance the weapon could be discharged accidentally, and your own legal rights could be at risk. Detaining someone with physical force until the police arrive is one thing, but holding them with the threat of gunfire is another. It's most likely going to work, but you may also be challenging an experienced criminal to call your bluff. Nothing could be much worse than being shot with your own weapon while waiting for trained help to arrive.

By anon150343 — On Feb 07, 2011

Can you make a citizens arrest with a weapon such as a firearm? for example, if there was a large amount of people doing an illegal act and could easily get away, could you pull a gun and tell them to get on the ground then call police and wait for them to arrive?

By anon111290 — On Sep 15, 2010

can a citizen use handcuffs to restrain the suspect he has arrested?

By anon91964 — On Jun 24, 2010

Can a citizens arrest be made for a person trying to hit you with their car and you are on a motorcycle?

By anon91140 — On Jun 20, 2010

can you citizen's arrest a person if he or she is attacking you in a fight or not?

By anon34968 — On Jul 01, 2009

why sensor police powers are no greater than yours or mine

By anon34967 — On Jul 01, 2009

you have a constitutional right to arrest but you will die from suicide by cop if you try to pierce the blue wall. Police don't live by same laws. Fear them

By anon34715 — On Jun 27, 2009

What about drinking, stagering to their car and gets in and starts to drive? Can you make an arrest and can you block them in or follow them then call the law or pull them over yourself?

By umadaop2 — On Jun 17, 2009

Can a citizen arrest a police officer or any law enforcement officer if they are committing a crime?

By anon31042 — On Apr 28, 2009

Cops can't arrest people for looking in car windows. People cry out for freedom then turn around and complain about the police/gov't for 'infringing' on their rights.

Come on now. The police show up to help when nobody else can. Give 'em a break.

By anon31020 — On Apr 28, 2009

The types who would attempt to make a citizens arrest would need to be self-righteous. In San Francisco, two plain cloths officers witnessed a man looking into cars, then broke a window, and pulled out a back pack. Then they arrested him. The cops waited for a crime to happen. In any case, leave it to the cops!

By takisv — On Oct 28, 2008

What are the 17 states that allow a private citizen to arrest for any public offense?

By rebel1 — On May 21, 2008

what is a persons responsibility once they have been put under citizens arrest?

By FPollock — On Jun 25, 2007

The writer suggests a rule of citizen's arrest which I think is too broad. In most states, a private citizen may arrest without a warrant when a felony has been committed and the citizen has reasonable grounds to believe that the person arrested is the one who committed it. If sued, the citizen does not have to prove the guilt of the arrestee, but must prove that the felony suspected was in fact committed. In a handful of states, the citizen must prove that the party arrested actually committed the felony.

As for offenses less than a felony, about seventeen states allow a private ciitzen to arrest for any public offense committed in his presence. But to justify the arrest, the citizen must show that the person arrested actually committed or attempted to commit the offense.

The scenario with the crowbar presents a different situation. The citizen may be justified in intervening to prevent a felony he reasonably believes is about to be committed in his presence. Also, if he owns the property that is about to be burglarized, he may interfere to defend his property. In either case, he may act on appearances, and will not be liable simply because appearances differ from actualities. But to say that a citizen may always act on reasonable appearances is too broad.

Michael Pollick
Michael Pollick
As a frequent contributor to Historical Index, Michael Pollick uses his passion for research and writing to cover a wide...
Learn more
Share
https://www.historicalindex.org/what-is-a-citizens-arrest.htm
Copy this link
Historical Index, in your inbox

Our latest articles, guides, and more, delivered daily.

Historical Index, in your inbox

Our latest articles, guides, and more, delivered daily.