History
Fact-checked

At HistoricalIndex, we're committed to delivering accurate, trustworthy information. Our expert-authored content is rigorously fact-checked and sourced from credible authorities. Discover how we uphold the highest standards in providing you with reliable knowledge.

Learn more...

Do Military Exercises Always Go as Planned?

Military exercises, designed to test and improve armed forces' readiness, often face unexpected challenges. Despite meticulous planning, variables like weather, equipment malfunctions, and human error can cause deviations. These hiccups provide valuable lessons, ensuring troops are adaptable in real conflict. Curious about what happens when drills diverge from the script? Dive deeper to uncover the resilience built through unpredictability.

War is hell, but even preparing for war can be pretty disastrous. One unfortunate example took place in 1944, as the American military was getting ready for the invasion of Normandy in hopes of ending World War II. Because the operation was so massive, U.S. commanders decided to run a rehearsal known as Exercise Tiger, prepping eight tank landing ships in an area of the English Channel known as Lyme Bay, off the coast of Devon and Dorset.

The ships carried hundreds of servicemen and equipment. Although live ammo was being used to make the exercise feel real, it was all supposed to be carried out quietly and in secret. But there was so much chatter on the radio that a group of German attack crafts became suspicious and discovered the operation. Without the presence of a destroyer to protect them -- one had been assigned the task but was pulled back for repairs -- the U.S. ships were easy targets for torpedoes.

A memorial to the servicemen killed during the Exercise Tiger rehearsal for D-Day, at Slapton Sands in Devon, England.
A memorial to the servicemen killed during the Exercise Tiger rehearsal for D-Day, at Slapton Sands in Devon, England.

The ensuing massacre cost the lives of nearly 800 Americans (or closer to 1,000 according to some reports), who were either killed in the fighting or died in the freezing water. Despite the catastrophe, news of the operation's failure was kept in check by U.S. leaders. The facts finally came to light decades later.

Some surprising facts about D-Day:

  • Part of the success of the Normandy invasion is credited to the decision to delay the attack one day, from June 5 to June 6, 1944, due to a forecast of bad weather.

  • President Teddy Roosevelt's son, Theodore Jr., was part of the first Allied group to land at Normandy beach. He was 56 years old and a general at the time.

  • Author J.D. Salinger was part of the second wave of men to land at Normandy, and he carried part of his novel The Catcher in the Rye with him.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do military exercises always go as planned?

No, military exercises do not always go as planned. Despite meticulous planning and coordination, unforeseen circumstances such as equipment failure, weather conditions, and human error can lead to deviations from the original plan. For instance, NATO's Trident Juncture exercise in 2018 faced challenges due to harsh weather conditions, which impacted the deployment of troops and equipment.

What are some common issues that can disrupt military exercises?

Common issues that can disrupt military exercises include technical malfunctions, communication breakdowns, weather-related challenges, and logistical complications. For example, during the Valiant Shield exercise in 2020, the U.S. Navy had to adapt to the challenges posed by the COVID-19 pandemic, which affected the movement and interaction of personnel.

How do militaries adapt when exercises don't go as planned?

Militaries adapt to unexpected developments during exercises by implementing contingency plans, adjusting tactics, and utilizing real-time problem-solving skills. These adaptations are crucial for maintaining operational readiness and achieving training objectives. The ability to adapt is itself a valuable outcome of these exercises, as it reflects real-world unpredictability.

Can unplanned events during military exercises provide learning opportunities?

Yes, unplanned events during military exercises can provide valuable learning opportunities. They allow military personnel to experience and manage real-world challenges, enhancing their decision-making, adaptability, and resilience. Such experiences contribute to the development of more robust strategies and tactics for future operations.

Are there any notable examples where military exercises did not go as planned?

One notable example is the Millennium Challenge 2002, where a series of war games conducted by the U.S. military did not go as planned. The opposing force, led by retired Marine Corps Lieutenant General Paul K. Van Riper, used unconventional tactics that resulted in the theoretical sinking of an entire U.S. carrier battle group, prompting a reset of the exercise and leading to significant debate about the exercise's format and assumptions.

You might also Like

Discuss this Article

Post your comments
Login:
Forgot password?
Register:
    • A memorial to the servicemen killed during the Exercise Tiger rehearsal for D-Day, at Slapton Sands in Devon, England.
      A memorial to the servicemen killed during the Exercise Tiger rehearsal for D-Day, at Slapton Sands in Devon, England.